[Mathew]

Mathew

You wrote-: "Tell me what you think she is doing and ill tell you why its wrong from pure logic...."

OK. I notice that her shoulder turn angle in the photo is roughly on the same plane angle as her clubshaft in the photo.

So you think the club, r shoulder, l shoulder, stationary point is somehow working on the same plane. Well ...obviously this is not happening on the downstroke nor is it happening at the top of the backstroke.

So, I presume that she is turning her shoulders in the downswing along a plane angle that is very close to being parallel to the inclined plane angle that her clubshaft will travel along when it passes through the impact zone.

Jeff.

So which now is it - is it parallel or is it on the same plane? You can't contradict yourself in the same post.

You can't take what I wrote and use a picture and say that it is mean't to be an exhibit to disprove me and now say this is an example of it (still not getting it right) just after making some statement about both shoulders and the club being onplane.

Tell me what you think happens in her stroke from the top of the backstroke where the right shoulder is on the inclined plane and then the left shoulder and stationary point is above the inclined plane to the picture in question and then tell me what you think it is mean't to portray.