Tumble... now I understand where you're coming from...

Like I said before, good luck, I hope it works well you! :)

Like i said- Just an experiment based on some reading.

But

Needing that luck. it is also good that this is a game to me. I am lucky that I dont use it to try and make a living.

I'll leave the original question and watch for substantive amplification.

The Bear

c'mon bear,

I am curious.

This is what we do here at LBG. Toss out ideas, dissect them and find out what they're really made of.

Describe the thrower so we can get a interesting discussion out of this.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ovGJv...ayer_embedded#!






HB

Hey Bear

In short , Id say that the Thrower pattern as outlined by Ralph Sunnyside can be found in the yellow book. But not as a "third category". RS defines three basic actions: muscular thrust , weight shift and rotation. Homer stuck to pushing vs pulling and didnt rank weight shift as even a power accumulator now that I think about it. Hmmmm. Its all a matter of definition again.

These sorts of discussions are really good I believe. Definition leading to identification . Identification to separation. Separation to mastery (or to insanity perhaps, not sure right now).

Couple of quick points:
-he's talking about hitting as a right arm punch , not so for Major Basic strokes....see what Homer termed the "Right Arm Throw". Its another throwing like motion this time with Active Right Arm extension. Push Basic is the inline punch of the right arm..........for short shots only.
-Hitters have pivot lag in Total Motion.
-I like D's point about longitudinal vs radial .......its a big subject so Im not going to start into it here. I love Bernts post too. In regard to what is mutually exclusive Id suggest that's it. You can not Longitudinal and Radial at the same time. (Can you?) Longitudinal then Radial? ....sure even 12-2 has Radial. In a motor boat pulling a skier kinda way (nothing pushes the skier radially, the boat turns around the small pulley wheel and cf throws the skier out, the speed of the skier going from the boats speed to boat speed plus plus). Or you could Radial only, 12-1 Drive Loading. (not the only way to hit by anymeans). But not Radial then Longitudinal or Longitudinal only. Longitudinal doest have any associated CF throwout. 'Cause its traveling in a straight line. If you're "arrow from quivering" you're not Releasing. This is the straight line hand path , be it theoretical or real.
-I thought I said I wasnt going to get into this, no I didnt, yes I did! ... .... ( No I didnt.) Uh Oh this aint mastery this is insanity.

Bad Subject?
 

Thanks O.B.

Perhaps the subject should not be approached.

There is sameness and difference.

As I understand. The sameness is in the 24 components. The differences are within the selection of elements within each of the 24.

HK says there is no THE WAY. Selection becomes personal.

BUT

2 categories were implicitly created, hit or swing, which may create a de facto THE WAY. 2 actions-hit or swing.

Should this be?

Chapter 12 creates a pattern selection process and these 2 selected patterns.

But aren't these patterns hortatory, not obligatory? Then why?

The only touch-point is 10-19-(A for one and C for the other or B for either)?

I did not push Humpty-Dumpty off the wall, I just nudged him, Chapter 14 is for pushing.


“I don’t know what you mean by ‘glory,’ ” Alice said.
Humpty Dumpty smiled contemptuously. “Of course you don’t—till I tell you. I meant ‘there’s a nice knock-down argument for you!’ ”
“But ‘glory’ doesn’t mean ‘a nice knock-down argument’,” Alice objected.
“When I use a word,” Humpty Dumpty said, in a rather a scornful tone, “it means just what I choose it to mean—neither more nor less.”
“The question is,” said Alice, “whether you can make words mean so many different things.”
“The question is,” said Humpty Dumpty, “which is to be master that’s all.”
Alice was too much puzzled to say anything, so after a minute Humpty Dumpty began again. “They’ve a temper, some of them—particularly verbs, they’re the proudest—adjectives you can do anything with, but not verbs—however, I can manage the whole lot! Impenetrability! That’s what I say!”

You’re going to have to ask the Judge what that means.

The Bear

Is there something outside of pushing and pulling? Can you longitudinal and radial at the same time? Can you walk in a circle and a straight line at the same time?

Ill ask Susan or John even, when Im ten feet tall............

I like the idea of "throwing the club," Bear and the intellectual exercise.
 

But I am limited to standing on the ground with two feet. I can either pull or push. I can rotate with either or both feet planted and then I both pull and push depending on the rest of the moves being made.

Now, "Alice" and her friends are works of fiction. I really like fiction but only as it furthers the understanding of facts. I can't remember the book title but the point of the book was that human language needs to be repetitive and a much smaller circle than pure mathematics since there is a very short list of what can happen to a person. There is "nothing new under the sun." However, there are new technologies that happen all the time. A person can hit a golf ball. They can hit it with lots of differing technologies. So the event list of what we can do is rather short but the instrument list is rather undefined. Jerry plays music but does so on different instruments in different places to differing degrees of excellence but it is still playing music.

We push and pull a golf club (nice and simple Bernt :) ) though we might have cork in the driver or Kevlar.

Alice and HD are arguing about something a lot less grounded than our biomechanical frame. You might be a reader of some of the literary dust-ups in England or France over the use of commas or what constitutes a "real" word. Good fun! And in your quote, as I understand it, HD is actually backing itself into Alice's point. Anyway, good fun, great book!

I would think that Ernest Jones would be an interesting study regarding this idea. Lag the penknife back and through but thrusting for him was tough, I bet.

ICT

I have a difficult time picturing how a person with two hands couldn't pull and push simultaneously.

Why couldn't they?

Works well for turning shopping carts.

Can the same hand push and pull? I don't see how.

Can one hand push and and hand pull? I don't see why not.

Is it a good thing? Wish I knew.

Seems like, in theory, it would be worth investigating.

In the World of TGM, Zone 2 is the application of mechanical advantage to increase Pivot Speed. The Straightening of the "Triangle" by Left Arm or Right Arm is mechanical advantage. The #2 Accumulator is also mechanical advantage whether it's passive or active, using CF or Power Package Thrust respectively. So, moving from bent to straight IS(part of) the mechanical advantage. It doesn't matter if you push or pull. That's only the "How". But the Pivot supplies all of the Power.

TGM is very much about the Pivot Supplying all of the Power (in Pivot Strokes). Somewhere it says that the arms should not substitute for the pivot.

Don't let me mislead you. The Arms are Power, but only in the sense that the Power comes from a "Pulley" or "Inclined Plane" or "Screw" or "Lever".

The Pivot is direct energy, stored by the Accumulators as Potential energy and released into Clubhead Kinetic Energy.

Anyway, I think I got most of that right. Pushing and Pulling is the "How" of Mechanical Advantage. Push and Pull is "How" the Accumulators are released. If three Accumulators aren't adding enough advantage, use four. That means you can store potential Power in 4 places, then increase or decrease their release overlap to refine.

Homer Kelley isn't saying that that's the way everybody gets the job done but he is saying that that's the way everybody "should" get the job done.

Mechanical Advantage is the factor by which a mechanism multiplies the force applied to it.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

This is just a personal note from me. It's unfortunate that TGM seems so focused on pulling and pushing. Homer gave everything equal emphasis but because component variations need to be chosen in light of Hitting or Swinging, it seems to have gotten a lot of "Press" time.

Pushing and pulling is rudimentary. Absorb Zone 1,2 and 3 and keep their identities separate. The magic, mystery, answers, are not found in Hitting vs Swinging.