| Daryl |
11-10-2009 09:12 AM |
Hogans secret is a long standing discussion. I don't know if there was any one secret, but it seems the more I read about them, the more I understand his component variations and swing but I don't claim to know his swing as well as others. It's difficult to analyze any swing. 3 or more books have already been written about his swing and after all of these years, no one swings like him yet.
I do think that Bending the left wrist at the Top of his Swing made a difference but at the expense of the Left Arm Wedge. At Release, it allows his left Arm to travel one plane while his Left Wrist Uncocked on the Elbow Plane. His Swivel Illustration in "Five Lessons" aptly demonstrates.
A Flat Left Wrist is necessary, from a TGM perspective, while on the Turned Shoulder Plane. To Uncock On the Swing Plane with a Flat Left Wrist, one needs the Left Arm Wedge On the Swing Plane Simultaneously. The #3 PP traces the Plane line. If the Left Arm is more Vertical to the Ground than the Swing Plane, as Hogan, then the Left Wrist needs to be bent to Uncock the Shaft On Plane.
In the picture below, Hogan appears to be Uncocking on a Vertical Plane. That would make any amount of Left Wrist Bend Unnecessary and render the above argument irrelevant. It looks like a Simultaneous Release. ??

|