Hinge Action not in Zone #3

[Mathew]

Thanks Mathew for the reply, however I find the reason you have given is inadequate for me. I hope those who agree are not agreeing just because Homer made the changes, ipso facto, it must be correct.

No, I did not elaborate, I just didn't want to write a thesis on the matter. Where you got the 'I'm just agreeing with Homer Kelley because he made the changes' like im a Homer drone with no brain...I do not know. Anyways, it is obvious that there are issues with hinge action on both clubhead control (angular motion) and the clubface control. Every procedure drives the primary lever assembly by creating a pressure against it which will naturally create a hinge action. Pivot driving the left arm - dual horizontal, Right forearm driving the left arm - angled... The difference right arm participation.... arms lane....

Its not to say that it doesn't belong in zone 3 either because the clubface motion through the ball is important...but there is a case for it being in zone 2. It is a grey area that Homer Kelley must of weighed up and this time chosen to be placed in zone 2.

[tongzilla]

No, I did not elaborate, I just didn't want to write a thesis on the matter. Where you got the 'I'm just agreeing with Homer Kelley because he made the changes' like im a Homer drone with no brain...I do not know. Anyways, it is obvious that there are issues with hinge action on both clubhead control (angular motion) and the clubface control. Every procedure drives the primary lever assembly by creating a pressure against it which will naturally create a hinge action. Pivot driving the left arm - dual horizontal, Right forearm driving the left arm - angled... The difference right arm participation.... arms lane....

Its not to say that it doesn't belong in zone 3 either because the clubface motion through the ball is important...but there is a case for it being in zone 2. It is a grey area that Homer Kelley must of weighed up and this time chosen to be placed in zone 2.

Mathew, I am not singling you out here! Sorry if my post sounded disparaging. Right Arm Thrust does indeed give a tendency towards Angle Hinging. However, one should be able to perform all three Hinge Actions with either Hitting or Swinging -- this is what Master's level of execution is about (3-F-6).