[whip]

DEAR OB LEFT if i may suggest some changes to your ideas on Right forearm pickup/takeaway

Although the pivot turns and seemingly provides the inward motion, it is the Right Forearm's job to lift the hands and clubhead ON PLANE, the pivot simply clears the way to allow this to happen easier and loads up any necessary pivot power. for the full swing, you will turn with it. when you are using a non pivot stroke the forearm must still lift the club and hands up on plane. The forearm, right tricep and #3 pp will transport the hands and clubhead up the plane with extensor action.

depending on the hinge action, loading action and basic stroke, the forearm will have varying degrees of fanning, for a swinger you will feel more than a tad of fanning, it is instant fanning and lifting, the hands turned on plane, per the swingers standard wrist action the #3 pp senses the gyroscope rotation immediately, it's pure fanning for the swinger. To ensure rhythm, the piston tracing and fanning must be dialed in for your particular pattern. the swinger has got a lot of fanning to do!

Sorry to be blunt, but the indian's "how" (not sure that's PC these days..) Ain't cuttin' it, there is more to it than just mimicking an indian, or cranking a lawnmower, it's all about your basic stroke being on the plane, whether it's push punch or pitch, for the swinger most likely pitch. The underhand pitch motion gives you a good feel for the proper fanning back and through to ensure rhythm.

personally i would forget about the lagging clubhead takeaway because, the motion here must be precise and upwards, not haphazardly dragging along the ground shut trying to feel a change in direction, forget about momentum in the startup, we want extensor, we want to be on plane with proper fanning and rhythm, and we want a swinging or hitting action.

forget about the divergent vectors, lift the club ON PLANE, instead of trying to mix and match vectors varying amounts to accommodate the plane.

Once again, FORGET ABOUT THE BACK(whole point of this thread), with extensor the natural structure of the arms will provide all the back you will ever need without actually going back at any point in the swing, from startup maintain extensor and lift the club UP AND IN immediately FORGET ABOUT THE BACK to top.

Width means maintaining the triangle (left arm radius) with extensor action.

It does not mean extending the triangle with extensor action.

Many who try for width, or 'low and slow' end up as you have described - incorrectly extending the triangle via the shoulder joint.

The macdonald drills are great but the right foream takeaway requires more precision than this, FORGET ABOUT GREAT SIMPLIFICATION for all of this, because it isn't simple. The right forearm takeaway is a precise motion based on your selected components that must have rhythm and be on plane. the plane is the boss and your loading, wrist action and hinge action are your bosses too. The only simplification is referencing your selected components and PRACTICING them on plane, as he says in 4-D-0 CONSTRUCT AN INCLINED PLANE.
Attachment 2847

FORGET SIMPLE, FORGET BACK, FORGET DIVERGENT VECTORS, FORGET LAGGING CLUBHEAD TAKEAWAY, MACDONALD DRILLS, ELK VIDEOS ETC.

THINK EXTENSOR, THINK #3PP, THINK LIFTING THE RIGHT FOREARM TO COCK THE LEFT WRIST, THINK FANNING, THINK ON PLANE, UP AND IN, WITH THE SELECTED WRIST ACTION, BASIC STROKE, HINGE ACTION AND LOADING ACTION. when this motion swings or carries the clubhead and hands to the top you will uncover the magic of the right forearm, and your downstroke blackouts will be fewer and farther between.

when working through basic and acquired motion this is your best chance to really work on the right forearm takeaway and you will learn it is not such a simple thing until you have mastered the proper motion and then you can wake up out of bed and lift the club up and in on plane with extensor in a deliberate and precise manner with action