Checking for On Plane Clubshaft

[lagster]

Thanks Strav.

This closely illustrates my point.

My interpretation:

The left model swing complies with 6-B-3-0-1. The right model swing Complies with 2-F by using a bent left wrist.

///////////////////////////////////

Is the green line in the model on the left... the path of the HANDS? The guy on the right looks like he might be one of the TURNING SHOULDER VERSIONS?

[neil]

///////////////////////////////////

Is the green line in the model on the left... the path of the HANDS? The guy on the right looks like he might be one of the TURNING SHOULDER VERSIONS?

I'm confused Lagster,the hands are on the green line-no?

[lagster]

I'm confused Lagster,the hands are on the green line-no?

/////////////////////////////////////////////

That's what it looks like to me. In the picture of the robot-man... the hands appear to be on the green line, and the clubhead and shaft on the red line. The green line is pointing well inside the baseline of the inclined plane.

[neil]

/////////////////////////////////////////////

That's what it looks like to me. In the picture of the robot-man... the hands appear to be on the green line, and the clubhead and shaft on the red line. The green line is pointing well inside the baseline of the inclined plane.

I was refering to the Hogan picture.The Robot man picture is mis leading because the green line represents -what?.The picture of robot man on the right is IMO NOT unskilled in terms of the hands and clubshaft being on plane.In the left hand graphic the view seems to be from in front of the line and I believe the the green line is meant to be the path of the hands which,if you were to rotate so you were looking down the line would lie on the red line.If anyone is saying that the hands can be on one plane and the clubshaft on another,then they are mistaken.