Tomasello Argument - Final Comment

[Delaware Golf]

What you say make sense in a pure feel system. TGM is more than that.

This has not been a debate because when a question is asked, the reply is an old magazine interview- one I believe was NOT intended to TEACH TGM.
The DOWN Stroke does not in 10-15-B START with the right forearm moving first. The Hips delay or FOLLOW on the up stroke and LEAD on the down stroke. A Hip Slide and Right Arm Throw is different than a Right Arm Throw and turn. Penick's "Magic Move" is simultaneous.
But I asked if this is what TT wants to happen in his stroke- that the right arm precede any Hip Motion. Does is lower hand position make a slide unnecessary? Simple questions - I don't want to read the magazine article again. Maybe some one else knows TT and can help out.

It's interesting that the 4 Barrel stroke pattern in the third edition which is a swinging pattern did not have a "Right Arm Throw Trigger", the 10-20 component is a "Wrist Throw". The Right Arm Throw Trigger appears to apply only to Hitting. However, the Magic of the Right Forearm action of bending and straightening the right elbow applies to both hitting and swinging (Hitting "Right Arm Throw"...Swinging "Wrist Throw").

DG