[quote=libero;42949][quote=SECGolf;42938]Having thought of this only because of personal experience (same problem), it really, really sounds like you are coming into impact over plane.
I'm not sure of what you mean by "over plane"; is that the same as "above
plane"? or you mean I'm reaching out with the clubhead beyond the plane
line?
Originally Posted by SECGolf
All you have to do is push (drive the door). All "timing" - when the door will line up with the frame - is taken care of by the hinge assembly.
Wait a minute...what am I supposed to push? I think only of pulling with my
left arm.
Anyway I thank you so much for all your precious infos.
Ciao
The base of an inclined plane is a straight line. When the shaft is not parrallel to the staight line (base of inclined plane), the end (of shaft - handle or clubhead) closest to the ground should point at this line ("on plane"). If you are right handed and the end is pointing to the right of the line you are over plane (shaft would be over a "real" inclined plane board - if you had one). Pointing to left side of plane line would indicate "under plane" - your chosen plane line.
"Push" - confusing choice of words on my part. Push only when referring to an actual door and its hinge assembly (and NOT for a swinging golf stroke procedure). In golf force is push of triceps - hitting - , centrifugal force - swinging . I believe these forces are what relates to pushing an actual door.
I believe the finish swivel is a result all that has come beforehand in a forceful, on plane golf swing. The finish swivel is allowed to happen.
Let me add some fog! It is possible to make a golf stroke such that the golf shaft always points at the target line. Such an action requires the least amount of physical effort by the golfer since all of one's effort is eventually directed at the ball. However, because of the human's bio-mechanical structure, to do so, the club shaft will always be swinging on very different inclined-planes. Dunn was wrong and Hogan very wrong, but they both were effective golfers.
Bagger,
You are right. I mis-wrote. Whenever the clubshaft is parallel to the ground, it points to aft and/or forward infinity and can't point at plane line. However, except for those brief moments, the rest of my comment is correct. Thanks for the correction.
Let me add some fog! It is possible to make a golf stroke such that the golf shaft always points at the target line. Such an action requires the least amount of physical effort by the golfer since all of one's effort is eventually directed at the ball. However, because of the human's bio-mechanical structure, to do so, the club shaft will always be swinging on very different inclined-planes. Dunn was wrong and Hogan very wrong, but they both were effective golfers.
Bump...
Still wait'in for some fog lifting xyz.
At some point in a full swing the clubshaft is typically parallel to the plane line during release and after follow through. Let's not forget about the end of the backswing as well. Three sections total.
Lets hear about it.
__________________
Bagger
1-H "Because of questions of all kinds, reams of additional detail must be made available - but separately, and probably endlessly." Homer Kelly
Let me add some fog! It is possible to make a golf stroke such that the golf shaft always points at the target line. Such an action requires the least amount of physical effort by the golfer since all of one's effort is eventually directed at the ball. However, because of the human's bio-mechanical structure, to do so, the club shaft will always be swinging on very different inclined-planes. Dunn was wrong and Hogan very wrong, but they both were effective golfers.
Yes it would be possible with on a putt. You would have to bend way over to do so.
Let me add some fog! It is possible to make a golf stroke such that the Hands always point at THE plane line. Such an action requires the least amount of physical effort by the golfer since all of one's effort is eventually directed at the aiming point. However, because of the human's bio-mechanical structure, to do so, the club shaft will always be swinging on very different inclined-planes. Dunn was wrong and Hogan very wrong, but they both were effective golfers.
A variation on the original question, edits in green....
__________________
"Support the On Plane Swinging Force in Balance"
"we have no friends, we have no enemies, we have only teachers"
Simplicity buffs, see 5-0, 1-L, 2-0 A and B 10-2-B, 4-D, 6B-1D, 6-B-3-0-1, 6-C-1, 6-E-2
Hybrid Mode
