[John Graham]

Interesting point but does that necessarily discount the net variances? Layback only vs closing only given the delofting you mention. There must still be a difference no?

The difference would come from club head speed and impact location.

I continue to be reminded to look at the picture in 2-C-2 and every time I do I see more questions.

For example, in 2-C-2 #2 and #3 it clearly shows a leaning forward shaft at impact and a vertical shaft at separation.

Surely, we can all agree that is an inaccurate representation of what happens in the time frame while the ball is on the face as depicted in these pictures.

I certainly agree with everyone, that vertical hinge action can be a wonderful teaching tool in the real world.

Am I the only one that see's this and has a desire to question it and learn more about it.

Is the picture an exaggeration?

If it is, is the whole thing an exaggeration or just the shaft depiction?

How would I know if just reading the book?

Should this picture be changed in the 8th edition?