O.B, HK is referring to putting when he says "Steeper than normal Elbow Plane".
Place the Grip in the cup of the Left Hand and adjust the right hand to correspond, then reach out with the arms to move the Right Elbow to the Steeper Plane. Then the Right Elbow, Right Forearm and Clubshaft are on the same Plane throughout the stroke. It's a "Straight Line Path" Elbow Plane. I'm sure that someone can make longer strokes and maybe use a Pivot Stoke too.
O.B, HK is referring to putting when he says "Steeper than normal Elbow Plane".
Place the Grip in the cup of the Left Hand and adjust the right hand to correspond, then reach out with the arms to move the Right Elbow to the Steeper Plane. Then the Right Elbow, Right Forearm and Clubshaft are on the same Plane throughout the stroke. It's a "Straight Line Path" Elbow Plane. I'm sure that someone can make longer strokes and maybe use a Pivot Stoke too.
I agree with the zeroing out of #3 Angle in Basic motion but I dont think Homer is talking Basic Motion there in that sentence in 7-23....unusual as that procedure seems.
Chapter 7 deals with the 24 Basic Components, 7-23 deals with the Power Package Delivery Path, " From the Top". The sentence in question deals with Straight Line Path vs Angled Delivery Paths similar I believe to the photos in the similarly numbered 10-23. Straight Line relating to Zero Shift , Angled to Double or Triple. He goes on to discuss Longitudinal and Radial.
D, I may be wrong , its easy to do with this stuff but Id say your definition of the Elbow Plane and Higher Elbow plane in that drawing is consistent with the 1st Edition but not the 3 rd on. Take a look at this photo, is that an Elbow Plane or a TSP Dianne has here Right Forearm on?
She has the Forearm resting on the TSP. But Her Right Arm Wedge is not On-Plane. Her Right Wrist is Fully Uncocked. The Purpose of the Photo is to illustrate the Angle of the TSP. In that it does that well is sufficient for the Photograph.
The Wedges have a very Specific Alignment to one another. But, is everyone aware that the Wedges also need to be aligned to the Swing-Plane? The Alignment to the Plane is substantially different on the TSP than on the Elbow Plane.
In 10-23 HK was explaining how to keep the Elbow Plane Alignment of the Wedges onto a Steeper Plane in order to use a Straight Line Path.
Guys I know we're supposed to be talking about Exit Plane but .......this is good stuff, it does relate. " What exactly are the Elbow and TSP planes. "
They get used really loosely , lets tighten em up definition wise. Its necessary, Id say, for proper discussions. Man I used to give Mike O a hard time about always defining things before discussing .........now Im Mr. Definition too. It works well at home too..... "Ah Honey what exactly do you mean when you tell me to "shut up" ? "
Anyhow ,if one of you have a picture from the yellow book for 10-6-A Elbow Plane please put it up. You'll see the Plane Board runs from the ball to the point where Diane's Right Elbow touches her side.
Quote:
10-6-A ELBOW Where the Right Elbow touches the waist is the reference point used for this Plane Angle. It is the “flattest” normal Plane that will still allow the Right Forearm to be On Plane during Impact. This should produce a very flat Angle of Attack (2-B) with reduced Backspin and should be avoided for Short Shots unless it is also part of your Full Stroke Pattern. The Elbow Plane allows maximum #3 Accumulator requiring earlier Release per 6-N-0. This procedure is executed by the Right Forearm per 7-3 and 10-6-B and Elbow Location per 6-B-3-0-1.
I dunno, I could be way wrong but it seems like there's one place where the elbow touches the side and a whole range of plane angles which the Right Forearm and Clubshaft can get on (between TSP and Elbow theoretically, if not practically).
Guys I know we're supposed to be talking about Exit Plane but .......this is good stuff, it does relate. " What exactly are the Elbow and TSP planes. "
They get used really loosely , lets tighten em up definition wise.
Agree- we got to nail this down before going on!
I will try and be simple and precise- (wish me luck)
That EP is going to swing around and get "steeper" and #2 and #3 are going to vanish. We are going to have both arms straight and pointed at the extended plane line. We will be on A TSP. We are going to call this beautifull place "follow-through".
From there we will swivel and glide on up to finish.
Hold-Rest, our work is done. How does it look? We "hope"? maybe with alignments we can change hope to understanding?? Ya think?.
Whether the clubshaft plane angle gets steeper, more shallow or stays the same after impact depends on what you do with your PP's pressure through impact and beyond. I think.
"Remember the Right Forearm is not “On Plane” unless the Right Elbow also is still – or again – On Plane (2-F)."
Because you leave -starting backswing- from impact fix and return to prior to impact. Chipping, you stay on EP
The/A TSP is a 1-L plane that also touches the right shoulder at TOP/END.
Hope I'm close to right.
The Bear
Im all for the Right Forearm being on Plane , I love the alignment personally. "No, you cant take that away from me".
I can work under either definition of Elbow Plane but lets ask Yoda for clarification and work under his definition.
"Yoda, if the Right Elbow is on Plane (through impact) is that an Elbow Plane? Despite the fact the Elbow and Shaft can align to higher planes such as the TSP per Homer. Does that make for a Elbow/TS Plane? How 'bout TSP is there a range?"
We "hope"? maybe with alignments we can change hope to understanding?? Ya think?.
Hybrid Mode
